AristotlePoeticsThe Primacy of Plot
Aristotle

The Primacy of Plot

5 min read · 0 reads

Against the intuition that character is what makes drama compelling, Aristotle argues that plot is primary. The soul of tragedy is not who the characters are but what happens to them — and through them, to us.

Plot as the Soul of Tragedy

Aristotle's ranking of tragedy's six elements — plot, character, thought, diction, song, spectacle — is deliberate and counterintuitive. We tend to remember great dramatic characters: Oedipus, Medea, Hamlet. But Aristotle insists that character is always in service of action. Tragedy imitates not men but actions and life. A drama without a well-constructed plot is not a drama at all; a drama without memorable characters may still be a tragedy.

The Plot, then, is the first principle, and, as it were, the soul of a tragedy: Character holds the second place.
Read in text · Ch. 2
Action, Not Quality

The distinction matters philosophically. Character determines what kind of person someone is — their qualities, dispositions, moral tendencies. But happiness and misery consist in action, in what we do and what is done to us. Life is lived as a sequence of events, not as a collection of traits. Drama, to be true to life, must imitate that sequence. The most beautiful colours laid on confusedly will not give as much pleasure as a chalk outline of a portrait.

Unity of Action

Unity of plot does not mean unity of hero. The Odyssey is not unified because Odysseus is one man — infinitely many incidents happened to him that Homer excluded. It is unified because Homer chose a single action — the return — and built everything else around it. Every incident must be such that its removal would dislocate and disturb the whole. An organic part is one whose presence or absence makes a visible difference.

The primacy of plot is argued in section VI; the unity of action in section VIII. Both are in Chapter 2 of this edition.

Related Concepts
φ
Select a book or concept to begin
Philosophi