David HumeAn Enquiry Concerning Human UnderstandingThe Bundle Theory of Self
David Hume

The Bundle Theory of Self

4 min read · 0 reads

When you look inward, what do you find? Descartes found a persisting thinking substance. Hume looked and found something quite different — only the thoughts, and no thinker.

No Self to Find

Hume reports that whenever he enters most intimately into what he calls himself, he always stumbles on some particular perception or other — heat or cold, love or hatred, pain or pleasure. He never catches himself without a perception. There is no bare self, only the stream of experience.

The mind is a kind of theatre where several perceptions successively make their appearance — there is properly no simplicity in it at one time, nor identity in different.
A Bundle of Perceptions

What we call the self is, on Hume's account, a bundle or collection of different perceptions united by certain relations — resemblance, causation, contiguity. Personal identity is a fiction we impose on the succession of experiences, not a metaphysical fact we discover.

Hume's bundle theory anticipates by two millennia the Buddhist doctrine of anattā — no-self. Both traditions deny a persisting substantial self and explain apparent continuity through causal and associative relations between momentary states.

Related Concepts
φ
Select a book or concept to begin
Philosophi