AristotleNicomachean EthicsThe Three Forms of Friendship
Aristotle

The Three Forms of Friendship

6 min read · 0 reads

Books VIII and IX of the Nicomachean Ethics contain the most sustained philosophical treatment of friendship in ancient philosophy. Aristotle's claim that friendship is not a supplement to the good life but a constituent of it — that no one would choose to live without friends even if they had everything else — has never been improved upon.

Three Kinds of Friendship

Aristotle distinguishes three forms of friendship according to what motivates them. Friendships of utility are held together by mutual benefit — when the benefit ceases, the friendship dissolves. Friendships of pleasure are held together by enjoyment of each other's company — common among the young, and equally temporary. Both are genuine friendships, but incomplete ones.

That then is perfect Friendship which subsists between those who are good and whose similarity consists in their goodness: for these men wish one another’s good in similar ways; in so far as they are good (and good they are in themselves); and those are specially friends who wish good to their friends for their sakes, because they feel thus towards them on their own account and not as a mere matter of result; so the Friendship between these men continues to subsist so long as they are good; and goodness, we know, has in it a principle of permanence.
Read in text · Ch. 8
The Perfect Friendship

The highest form is friendship between people who are good and similar in virtue. These friends value each other not for what they receive but for what the other is. Because character is stable, such friendships endure. Because each genuinely wishes the other well, they call forth the best in each other — spending time together, sharing their lives, taking pleasure in each other's activities. This is friendship in the fullest sense.

And further, the Friendship of the good is alone superior to calumny; it not being easy for men to believe a third person respecting one whom they have long tried and proved: there is between good men mutual confidence, and the feeling that one’s friend would never have done one wrong, and all other such things as are expected in Friendship really worthy the name; but in the other kinds there is nothing to prevent all such suspicions.
Read in text · Ch. 8
A Friend as a Second Self

Aristotle's deepest claim about friendship is that a genuine friend is a second self. To love a friend in the proper sense is to extend to them the same concern for flourishing that the good person properly has for themselves. This connection between self-love and friendship is characteristic of Aristotle's approach: the person who does not properly value their own rational nature cannot genuinely value it in another.

Friendship and the Political Community

Friendship is not merely a private matter. Aristotle explicitly connects it to justice and to the bonds that hold political communities together. The goodwill, mutual recognition, and concern for the other's well-being that characterise friendship are also the dispositions that make civic life possible. A city of strangers who merely tolerate each other is a diminished community compared to one whose citizens share the kind of concord that Aristotle identifies with civic friendship.

Friendship is treated across Books VIII and IX of the Nicomachean Ethics, in what remains the most comprehensive philosophical treatment of philia in the ancient world.

Related Concepts
φ
Select a book or concept to begin
Philosophi